Skip to content

Past event

Has Quality Killed Teaching? Exploring the Crisis in Teacher Recruitment and Retention

In recent years, the teaching profession has faced an unprecedented crisis, with alarming rates of teacher shortages and high turnover rates across the globe. As the demands on educators continue to escalate, fuelled by rigorous accountability measures and ever-increasing regulatory requirements, a critical question arises: Has the relentless pursuit of quality inadvertently undermined the very foundation of teaching as a career?

Recent studies have highlighted the detrimental impact of excessive workloads and mounting accountability pressures on teachers’ mental health and job satisfaction. A report by the Education Support Partnership (2021) revealed that a staggering 77% of teachers in the UK experienced mental health issues due to their work, with workload being cited as the primary cause. Similarly, a study by the National Foundation for Educational Research (NFER, 2022) found that nearly one-third of teachers in England were considering leaving the profession within the next five years, citing excessive workload and accountability pressures as significant contributing factors. High-stakes accountability measures, such as Ofsted inspections, are seen to impact on teacher morale and retention. A report for the National Education Union by researchers at UCL (2023) revealed that the intense pressure associated with Ofsted inspections often leads to increased stress levels, burnout, and a narrowing of the curriculum, ultimately undermining the very quality of education these measures aim to promote.

This panel discussion will provoke and challenge, shedding light on the complex interplay between regulatory body expectations and school-based teacher and school leader experience.  Drawing upon the latest research findings, this academic discourse aims to unravel the intricate dynamics at play and explore potential solutions to this multifaceted challenge.

Attendees can expect to gain valuable insights into the following key areas:

  1. The Impact of Accountability Measures: Examining the unintended consequences of high-stakes inspections and regulatory frameworks on teacher morale, job satisfaction, and retention rates.
  2. Redefining Quality: Exploring alternative approaches to quality assurance that prioritise teacher well-being, professional development, and re-establish teaching as a graduate career of choice.
  3. Policy Implications: Discussing potential policy reforms and strategies to address the teacher recruitment and retention crisis.

As the teaching profession navigates these challenging times, the “Has Quality Killed Teaching?” panel discussion promises to be a thought-provoking and insightful exploration of one of the most pressing issues facing the education sector today.

Draft Programme:

09:00

Welcome & Introduction
Tanya Ovenden-Hope & Vicky Bamsey, Educational Effectiveness and Improvement SIG Convenors

09:10 Panel Discussion
Tanya Ovenden-Hope, Plymouth Marjon University
Jo Lampert, Monash University
Larissa McClean-Davies, University of Melbourne
Amy McPherson, University of Newcastle, Australia
Clare Brooks, University of Cambridge
Beng Huat-See, University of Birmingham
09:50 Summary
10:00 Event Close

 

Chairs and Speakers

Profile picture of Tanya Ovenden-Hope
Tanya Ovenden-Hope, Professor

Professor of Education & Dean at Plymouth Marjon University

Professor Tanya Ovenden-Hope is Provost and Professor of Education at Plymouth Marjon University. In 2018 she developed and opened Marjon University Cornwall based in Truro, which she leads. Tanya is a committed and enthusiastic educationalist...

Profile picture of Victoria Bamsey
Victoria Bamsey, Dr

Lecturer at University of Plymouth

As a lecturer in Early Childhood Studies and Education and Programme Lead for the National Award for SEN Coordination at the University of Plymouth I am interested in questioning education, what education means, what it looks like and where it...

Profile picture of Clare Brooks
Clare Brooks, Professor

Professor of Education at University of Cambridge

Clare Brooks is Professor of Education at the University of Cambridge. Following her experience as a teacher of geography in east London, her research interests are still geographical, specifically in spatial justice and teacher education. She...

Profile picture of Beng Huat See
Beng Huat See, Professor

Prof of Education Research at Durham University

Beng Huat See is a professor in the Department of Teacher Education, University of Birmingham, UK. Her work largely involves reviews and synthesis of evidence in education, evaluation of large-scale intervention programmes, and re-analysis of...

Profile picture of Jo Lampert
Jo Lampert, Professor

Professor of Teacher Education for Social Transformation at Monash University

Jo Lampert is Professor of Teacher Education for Social Transformation in the School of Education, Culture and Society at Monash University in Melbourne, Australia. Known for her work in leading two large Australian social justice teacher...

Profile picture of Amy McPherson
Amy McPherson, Dr

Senior Lecturer at University of Newcastle, Australia

Dr Amy McPherson is a Senior Lecturer and member of the Teachers and Teaching Research Centre at the University of Newcastle, Australia. She is currently a chief investigator of an Australian Research Council exploring the impacts of teacher...

Profile picture of Larissa McLean Davies
Larissa McLean Davies, Associate Professor

Associate Dean (Learning and Teaching) at University of Melbourne

Larissa McLean Davies leads large-scale Teacher Education research which mobilises partnerships with Government agencies, Education Departments, and not-for-profit organisations. Her mission is to convene interdisciplinary, translational research...

Content related to this event